About to get on the spitting side of he-who-knows-stuff here, but so be it.
Today the Strib ran this piece:
Barely scraping by on minimum wage
It's 6 a.m. and Sonny Benettie is lining up to grab a work slip at Labor Ready, a day labor center on St. Paul's University Avenue. For $6.75 an hour, he'll unload 6,000 pounds of furniture at a home in Eagan for a couple hours and come back tomorrow hoping for another slip.
"It's hard to describe unless you've lived like this, but even people who haven't been there know you can't live on a minimum wage of $5.15 an hour — or even $7 an hour," said Benettie, 54. "You're not living, you're just existing."
Fifty. Four.
Ahem. Not to sound cruel. But, hey big-ass paper who perports investigative abilities? Why is a 54 year old man working entry level, manual labor kind of jobs? Yeah, yeah, I know. Government budget cuts, and stuff. But what do we know about THIS fellow? You spoke to him. He's 54 and still only earning entry level wages. Do we here a "why"? Nope. Instead we move on to...
It's nearing midnight at the Golden Chicken, a takeout and delivery spot in north Minneapolis where Amanda Hildebrand, 22, puts in about 25 hours a week at $5.15 an hour. To pay the bills, she pools resources with four other low-earners who share a duplex.
According to a study from the state Labor and Industry Department, Hildebrand fits the profile of the state's 49,000 minimum-wagers. More than one-third of them work preparing and serving food. More than half are between age 15 and 24, and women are nearly twice as likely to be making the minimum as men.
Um... hey Strib! Want to get an exclusive? I lived that same freaking life-style.
See, I graduated from college, with a liberal-arts degree, but not much direction where I should go in life. So I worked in a pizza place. I made pizza's - I liked that. And then I was a waiter. Different town. Didn't like that.
And then life hit me in the face enough times that I figured out a way to apply my education to better employment.
And this is different from these 15-24 year old "crisis" kids, how?
Benettie and Hildebrand offer a glimpse into a working world without benefits or paid vacations where a car, gas and insurance are often out of reach.
Hey. Screw You. I lived that life. For a long time. You know what my freakin' honeymoon was? The wife got the day off work. Blow the paid freakin' vacations out your *ss.
And not to beat a dead horse, but since they want to use it to sucker all of us...
In many ways, Benettie is already devastated. He has no permanent address and hops between friends' couches.
"Affordable living is out of the question when you're making six bucks an hour," he said.
Benettie grew up in rural Mississippi, served as a Marine in the Vietnam War and has lived in the Twin Cities for 25 years. He has been a dishwasher at a local college and worked for various hauling companies over the years.
When his ex-wife lost her sales job because of a department store closing in the late-1990s, "the bills piled up sky-high" and so did the tension. He was convicted of fifth-degree domestic assault in 2001 and spent a year in prison in Faribault. With a felony on his record, a steady job is hard to find.
Gosh. I am shocked to discover a felony involved.
Look, if you want charity for felons, be honest enough to ask for it. Don't cast it as a rich v. poor issue, because too many of us have lived on both sides of that line to believe you.
But the other piece missing in all of this is Chemical Dependency and Mental Illness issues. Between the felon status, and the CD and MI issues, it becomes nearly impossible for anyone 54 years of age to secure any kind of meaningful, decent-paying employment without serious intervention.
There are many private and public agencies - like the Department of Rehabilitation Services - prepared to step in and help such folks, but client has to want the help and they have to be willing to work hard with DRS workers to get their lives back in order.
Trouble ie, even if they do everything right, from here on out, who's going to hire a 54 year-old ex-con with a lifetime of screwing up? It's usually so difficult that most just give up. Still, it's hardly society's fault for that lifetime of screwing up, is it? (Of course, Saint Nick would say that it is...)
It's not that I feel no compassion for someone like Benettie. It's that I'm not going to be emotionally blackmailed into raising the minimum wage over his story. And that is exactly how the Strib positioned this issue.
Muzzy's point is much more relevant to such cases than the minimum wage issue. And Mitch Berg noted some systematic problems with the domestic felony system (about which I have to claim total ignorance), which also sounds closer to the mark.
Getting beyond tweaking the correct matters of policy, the proper response to hard-luck cases ought to be charity. Government doesn't handle poverty well. Therefore I'm agin' it.
Is the minimum wage too low or does too much of it go to the government in the form of taxes?