Bogus Gold

Meh!!!

I'm a Coldhearted Bastard
About to get on the spitting side of he-who-knows-stuff here, but so be it.

Today the Strib ran this piece:

Barely scraping by on minimum wage


It's 6 a.m. and Sonny Benettie is lining up to grab a work slip at Labor Ready, a day labor center on St. Paul's University Avenue. For $6.75 an hour, he'll unload 6,000 pounds of furniture at a home in Eagan for a couple hours and come back tomorrow hoping for another slip.

"It's hard to describe unless you've lived like this, but even people who haven't been there know you can't live on a minimum wage of $5.15 an hour — or even $7 an hour," said Benettie, 54. "You're not living, you're just existing."


Fifty. Four.

Ahem. Not to sound cruel. But, hey big-ass paper who perports investigative abilities? Why is a 54 year old man working entry level, manual labor kind of jobs? Yeah, yeah, I know. Government budget cuts, and stuff. But what do we know about THIS fellow? You spoke to him. He's 54 and still only earning entry level wages. Do we here a "why"? Nope. Instead we move on to...


Mama E (mail) (www):
Now I don't usually comment on my other half's sight but this time I will. For the first 5 years that we were together (co-habitating and then married) we lived at or below the poverty line. At the time, it sucked. We frequently had to choose whether to pay a bill or eat. Fruit was a luxury that we seldom enjoyed. And I became really good at squeezing the Banquet Chicken Dinner boxes to find the ones with fatter pieces of chicken. We had a futon mattress(no frame) for a bed, the parents old couch for livingroom furniture, and nothing else in our run down 1 bedroom, no shower, plagued apartment, which flooded 2 weeks before we moved and we lost 80% of our belongings. We both worked, I was still in college, and a vacation meant that we both had 2 days off at the same time. We worked hard, played little, and realized that if we wanted better, we had to work even harder. And so we did. I worked my way up from line cook to restaurant manager for a restaurant chain, which transferred us up to MN. Doug took a temp job as a receptionist/shipping assistant. I used my restaurant experience and college degree in biology to get a job that actually required both qualifications. Doug honed his skills to become a full time computer guy. And on and on we went. Five years later we took our first vacation EVER. We were 27/28 years old. The post highschool/college years are tough. Like many others we struggled but eventually we grew up and took responsibility for our lives. These 15-24 year olds are living a typical life that has been lived by many before them. As far as the "more women than men" comment; I know more than a few post college professional woman that work part-time as waitresses or bartenders because with just a few hours they can make a LOT of money in tips. This is also a common job for stay at home moms. As far as the 54 year old, well Doug said it well enough. The guy made some bad choices and he is having to deal with the consequences. Life is about choices. And yes, sometimes bad things happen but that doesn't mean that it was some evil plan of society nor does society needs to fix these issues. The Lord helps those who help themselves. I doubt there will a follow-up story in 5 years. And finally, I actually look back at our years of struggle as fond and sometimes funny memories. Those years brought us to where we are today. Married for 13 years(today is our anniversary), 3 children, and a wonderful yet sometimes chaotic life.
3.28.2005 9:58am
Margaret (www):
You are a coldhearted bastard Doug. I felt some compassion for Mr. Benettie. The guy has screwed up his life, no doubt about it. He admits as much. I'm willing to admit that a 54 year old unskilled felon is going to have problems finding more than a minimum wage job. Why he can't get more training or a better job is probably as simple as he doesn't know how to navigate the job bureaucracy. I'm totally with you on the 15-24 year old crisis. 15-17 your full time job should be school. Why should we care if you can't make more than minimum wage? In fact, more than minimum wage is going incentive-ize leaving school for more kids.
3.28.2005 10:03am
Muzzy (mail) (www):
Yeah, I remember working minimum wage, with no bennies. I was young then, and fairly healthy. It was ok. I just lived with roomies and tried to economize. I never went hungry.

But the other piece missing in all of this is Chemical Dependency and Mental Illness issues. Between the felon status, and the CD and MI issues, it becomes nearly impossible for anyone 54 years of age to secure any kind of meaningful, decent-paying employment without serious intervention.

There are many private and public agencies - like the Department of Rehabilitation Services - prepared to step in and help such folks, but client has to want the help and they have to be willing to work hard with DRS workers to get their lives back in order.

Trouble ie, even if they do everything right, from here on out, who's going to hire a 54 year-old ex-con with a lifetime of screwing up? It's usually so difficult that most just give up. Still, it's hardly society's fault for that lifetime of screwing up, is it? (Of course, Saint Nick would say that it is...)
3.28.2005 10:32am
Doug:
Maragret,

It's not that I feel no compassion for someone like Benettie. It's that I'm not going to be emotionally blackmailed into raising the minimum wage over his story. And that is exactly how the Strib positioned this issue.

Muzzy's point is much more relevant to such cases than the minimum wage issue. And Mitch Berg noted some systematic problems with the domestic felony system (about which I have to claim total ignorance), which also sounds closer to the mark.

Getting beyond tweaking the correct matters of policy, the proper response to hard-luck cases ought to be charity. Government doesn't handle poverty well. Therefore I'm agin' it.
3.28.2005 10:55am
Anonymous:
Point of interest, a 5th degree felony resulting in 1 year of prison means he has committed the same offense on the same person within 5 years. This man's inability to get a job has nothing to do with the minimum wage but instead his felony conviction. Even with skills training, it would be unlikely for him to be hired because it would put the hiring company at risk for liability if he would assault another employee. Would any of you like someone you love to be exposed to this type of risk on a daily basis? And who would you hold responsible if something horrible happened?

Is the minimum wage too low or does too much of it go to the government in the form of taxes?
3.28.2005 1:01pm
DrJonz (www):
So what happened to the concept of working 2-3 jobs? If it was good enough for me, my family, my father-in-law, etc., it's good enough for anyone else. Communists who disagree can go to the hell they don't believe in.
3.29.2005 5:15pm

Post as: [Register] [Log In]

Account:
Password:
Remember info?