Bogus Gold

Wanted: One Monkey

A Question of Ethics
How would you feel about someone deciding to post the names and addresses of every homosexual he knew about on the Internet? Let's further stipulate that this wouldn't violate any laws, because he'd obtain all the name and address info through public sources.

Would a person who published such a list be considered a "good guy," or a "bad guy" in your book? Is this behavior ethical in your opinion?

How about if the situation I described above was just slightly altered?

A pair of gay activists are raising the stakes in the fight over same-sex marriage, vowing to post on the Internet the name and address of anyone who signs a petition to ban gay marriage and civil unions in Massachusetts.

Discuss.
Posted by Doug Williams on Friday September 9, 2005 at 11:26am
Kathy (www):
Provided the information does come from public sources and is not innuendo or rumor it's ethical. Perhaps it's not pleasant, but it is ethical.
9.9.2005 12:14pm
Jeff (mail) (www):
Ok...I'll bite. Just how is this ethical? How is posting the names and addresses (on the internet or anywhere) of people who sign a petition for anything in this country ethical when used as a means of discouraging people from exercising their rights as citizens?

Ethics is defined as a set of principles of right conduct. How would posting the names of people who sign a petition fall within that definition?
9.9.2005 12:34pm
Muzzy (www):
Can't agree with Kathy here. Posting such information may be legal, but it is being done to harrass and intimidate those who do not hold a particular view on an issue, therefore it is immoral and wrong to do so. The law should be changed to reflect this reality, although in Minnesota the anti-stalking laws might provide some injunctive relief.
9.11.2005 12:48am
Tony (mail) (www):
OK, then maybe the picture of each person entering an abortion clinic should be posted with the location of the clinic.

Maybe pictures of the people in Alcholics Anonymous with their first name...after all, they are in a public gathering and volunteering their first names.
9.11.2005 9:19am

Post as: [Register] [Log In]

Account:
Password:
Remember info?