Bogus Gold

Wanted: One Monkey

Down With The Cork!
Professor Bainbridge has an excellent article at TCS Daily on the great cork versus screwcap debate in the wine world.

I like old things. Old ideas. Old books. Old wines. I guess that's part of the reason I'm a conservative. Yet, the intelligent conservative combines a disposition to preserve with an ability to reform. And so we come to the question of closures for wine. ...

So what’s the answer? I hate to say it, but I am persuaded that the answer is the Stelvin screw cap.

Lot's more good stuff and plenty of linkage in the rest of the article.

As many of you know, I'm a tremendous advocate of getting rid of cork, due to personal experience losing far too many good wines to cork-taint. As research increasingly demonstrates that there are alternatives which retain the upside of natural cork's ideal rate of oxidation while removing the downside of spoiled wine, I'm hopeful the wine industry will quickly move to adopt them.

(P. S. Note the redesign of the former TechCentralStation site, now TCS Daily? I'm personally quite impressed.)
Posted by Doug Williams on Monday December 12, 2005 at 7:30pm
The Ohligarch (mail) (www):
"This wine is corked."

"No, I've just UN-corked it!"
12.13.2005 4:23pm
Surly Dave (mail) (www):
I had a clerk at a liquor store give me the most incredulous look I've ever recieved when I returned a bottle for being corked (as-in "gone bad"). He treated me like an idiot until I called out his manager and ripped into him for not training his employees. Turns out he didn't know the term either, and didn't understand that as much as 10 % of wine goes bad due to cork failure. That store eventually closed up. No loss.
12.13.2005 6:46pm
Scott Ferguson (mail) (www):
I worked at Surdyk's in NE Mpls during college. I don't live in the area and I don't drink anymore, but if I did, I would still be a patron. The Surdyk family (fine people) and their staff have deep knowledge about the wines and spirits they offer. And they WILL take back a bad bottle!
12.14.2005 1:47pm
Doug (www):
Wow Scott. Surdyk's is without a doubt the finest wine &spirits store in the Twin cities. I'm envious that you once worked there.

But it is true that the majority of wine &liquor store employees have no idea what corked wine is. Sometimes if the bottle isn't too expensive, I just dump it and write it off to avoid the hassle of returning it.
12.14.2005 1:54pm

Post as: [Register] [Log In]

Account:
Password:
Remember info?